Its like Dr. Buss is guarding the Celtic rim this second half. Nothings dropping
Its like Dr. Buss is guarding the Celtic rim this second half. Nothings dropping
trodgers wrote:Honestly, the question is absurd, as no one really looks at the relevant data when trying to evaluate this causal claim. Here is a ridiculous amount of data. I look just at LA's losses in December, broken down by Quarter. I look at Kobe's FG attempts per 12 minutes, the +/- with him on the floor.
First Q
Average: 7.3 FGA/12 minutes
Average +/-: -1.5
Wins: 3
Losses: 3
>6 FGA/12: 2 wins, 2 losses
</=6 FGA/12: 1 win, 1 loss
Second Q
Average: 8.4 FGA/12 minutes
Average +/-: -5.7
Wins: 1
Losses: 4
Ties: 1
>6 FGA/12: 0 win, 3 losses, 1 tie
</=6 FGA/12: 1 win, 1 loss
Entered Losing: 1 win, 3 losses
Entered Winning: 0 wins, 1 tie, 1 loss
Entered Winning + Shot 6+/12: 0 wins, 1 tie, 1 loss (13.6 FGA/12)
Third Q
Average: 6.8 FGA/12 minutes
Average +/-: +3.7
Wins: 4
Losses: 1
Ties: 1
>6 FGA/12: 3 wins, 1 tie
</=6 FGA/12: 1 win, 1 loss
Entered Losing: 3 win, 0 losses, 1 tie
Entered Winning: 0 win, 1 loss
Entered Winning + Shot 6+/12: 0 wins, 1 loss (6 FGA/12)
Fourth Q
Average: 9.9 FGA/12 minutes
Average +/-: -2.8
Wins: 2
Losses: 3
Ties: 1
>6 FGA/12: 2 wins, 3 losses, 1 tie
</=6 FGA/12: 0 games
Entered Losing: 2 wins, 1 loss, 1 tie
Entered Winning: 0 win, 2 losses
Entered Winning + Shot 6+/12: 0 wins, 2 loss (12.5 FGA/12)
So, in order to test a causal claim, look at "Losses" given "Shoots a lot" and "Losses" given "Doesn't shoot a lot"
In Quarters in which the team was winning when Kobe entered and in which he shot 6+ times, the Lakers were 0-4-1; he shot an average of 11.6 times in those quarters.
In Quarters in which the team was winning when Kobe entered, the Lakers were 0-4-1.
In other words, I think there is insufficient evidence here to make a claim, as there is no legit contrast class.
If we go by wins vs. losses (and ties):
Wins: 10 Kobe shoots an average of 7.2/12 min
Losses: 11 Kobe shoots an average of 9.4/12 min
Ties: 3 Kobe shoots an average of 12.2/12 min
puffyusaf#2 wrote:In my simple opinion: No.

Doc Brown wrote:His defense is the biggest issue, Kobe shooting translates to points, his defense negates that and puts us in a hole.....
When you're telling arguably the greatest SCORER in the NBA to play PG and have the ball in his hands for a majority of the time, what do you think will happen? He's got the ball more often, he knows he can score, he's going to work, that's just his mentality.
When Nash comes back, Kobe won't have the ball in his hands as much and will be taking less shots at a better clip.
As far as his shots right now, it's tough because you would have to go back and look at everyone because truthfully, IMO, he's not taking that many BAD shots. He just has his hands on the ball so much that it's just bound to equal more shot attempts. He's not a PG, he's not going to magically defer to everyone.
What needs to happen is when others get the ball, they need to be aggressive. It's pretty clear that when everyone goes passive, Kobe gets aggressive and vice versa. Finding that happy medium would be ideal, but it's on both parties to do it.
Its like Dr. Buss is guarding the Celtic rim this second half. Nothings dropping
wcsoldier81 wrote:I see it this way :
- I don't like games in which Kobe plays 1 on 5 as soon as the game starts ( Houston , Cleveland by instance this season ) because you can feel these are automatic losses ... the rest of the team isn't involved and plays disinterested on both ends off the floor
- Kobe ball has won very few games against a quality opponent for the latest 3 seasons so even when the rest of the team is struggling shooting the ball ( which is far to be the case in every game Kobe shoots a lot) , Kobe taking the majority of the shots won't work ...
the pb ? Every player stays passive and passes to Kobe on every possession ... the only player who would make a play is Metta ... a disaster waiting to happen for the most part... and Dwight is an interior player so somebody has to pass him the rock if he wants to make something happen.
That's why Nash return will be big ... finally a perimeter who will understand when the team has to stay away from Kobe ball , keep everybody involved AND is competent to make a play... especially down the stretch.
I couldn't care less about our team record when Kobe scores over 30 or attempts 20+ FG ...
Kobe ball hasn't been working at all for the last 2-3 seasons so KEEP PLAYING AS A TEAM

Armani wrote:Kobe has a tendency to jack up a couple WTF type of shots every game, but he's not what's hurting the Laker O... that falls on the inconsistency of role-players, who sometimes fail to hit their shots consistently because MDA forces them to chuck up 3's whenever they get the ball.
Kobe's main problem is on D... not the O. Without him, the Laker O is usually lost... unless Meeks is having one of his hot streaks. Dwight's impact on O hasn't been all that great so far.
wcsoldier81 wrote:I see it this way :
- I don't like games in which Kobe plays 1 on 5 as soon as the game starts ( Houston , Cleveland by instance this season ) because you can feel these are automatic losses ... the rest of the team isn't involved and plays disinterested on both ends off the floor
- Kobe ball has won very few games against a quality opponent for the latest 3 seasons so even when the rest of the team is struggling shooting the ball ( which is far to be the case in every game Kobe shoots a lot) , Kobe taking the majority of the shots won't work ...
the pb ? Every player stays passive and passes to Kobe on every possession ... the only player who would make a play is Metta ... a disaster waiting to happen for the most part... and Dwight is an interior player so somebody has to pass him the rock if he wants to make something happen.
That's why Nash return will be big ... finally a perimeter who will understand when the team has to stay away from Kobe ball , keep everybody involved AND is competent to make a play... especially down the stretch.
I couldn't care less about our team record when Kobe scores over 30 or attempts 20+ FG ...
Kobe ball hasn't been working at all for the last 2-3 seasons so KEEP PLAYING AS A TEAM
Greatest of All Time wrote:trodgers wrote:Honestly, the question is absurd, as no one really looks at the relevant data when trying to evaluate this causal claim. Here is a ridiculous amount of data. I look just at LA's losses in December, broken down by Quarter. I look at Kobe's FG attempts per 12 minutes, the +/- with him on the floor.
First Q
Average: 7.3 FGA/12 minutes
Average +/-: -1.5
Wins: 3
Losses: 3
>6 FGA/12: 2 wins, 2 losses
</=6 FGA/12: 1 win, 1 loss
Second Q
Average: 8.4 FGA/12 minutes
Average +/-: -5.7
Wins: 1
Losses: 4
Ties: 1
>6 FGA/12: 0 win, 3 losses, 1 tie
</=6 FGA/12: 1 win, 1 loss
Entered Losing: 1 win, 3 losses
Entered Winning: 0 wins, 1 tie, 1 loss
Entered Winning + Shot 6+/12: 0 wins, 1 tie, 1 loss (13.6 FGA/12)
Third Q
Average: 6.8 FGA/12 minutes
Average +/-: +3.7
Wins: 4
Losses: 1
Ties: 1
>6 FGA/12: 3 wins, 1 tie
</=6 FGA/12: 1 win, 1 loss
Entered Losing: 3 win, 0 losses, 1 tie
Entered Winning: 0 win, 1 loss
Entered Winning + Shot 6+/12: 0 wins, 1 loss (6 FGA/12)
Fourth Q
Average: 9.9 FGA/12 minutes
Average +/-: -2.8
Wins: 2
Losses: 3
Ties: 1
>6 FGA/12: 2 wins, 3 losses, 1 tie
</=6 FGA/12: 0 games
Entered Losing: 2 wins, 1 loss, 1 tie
Entered Winning: 0 win, 2 losses
Entered Winning + Shot 6+/12: 0 wins, 2 loss (12.5 FGA/12)
So, in order to test a causal claim, look at "Losses" given "Shoots a lot" and "Losses" given "Doesn't shoot a lot"
In Quarters in which the team was winning when Kobe entered and in which he shot 6+ times, the Lakers were 0-4-1; he shot an average of 11.6 times in those quarters.
In Quarters in which the team was winning when Kobe entered, the Lakers were 0-4-1.
In other words, I think there is insufficient evidence here to make a claim, as there is no legit contrast class.
If we go by wins vs. losses (and ties):
Wins: 10 Kobe shoots an average of 7.2/12 min
Losses: 11 Kobe shoots an average of 9.4/12 min
Ties: 3 Kobe shoots an average of 12.2/12 min
Kobe Bryant can never take too many shots
Can you explain the wins and losses? Is one win counted as having a + for a quarter, is one loss counted as having a - for a quarter and is a tie counted as having 0 for a quarter? Also, I noticed you're counting FGA/12 min. Are they adjusted per 12 minutes stats?
Might I suggest also considering something like the average scoring efficiency during that time. (FG%, points per shot, whatever) Can't blame a guy for shooting if he's making them mirite?
Doc Brown wrote:His defense is the biggest issue, Kobe shooting translates to points, his defense negates that and puts us in a hole.....
When you're telling arguably the greatest SCORER in the NBA to play PG and have the ball in his hands for a majority of the time, what do you think will happen? He's got the ball more often, he knows he can score, he's going to work, that's just his mentality.
When Nash comes back, Kobe won't have the ball in his hands as much and will be taking less shots at a better clip.
As far as his shots right now, it's tough because you would have to go back and look at everyone because truthfully, IMO, he's not taking that many BAD shots. He just has his hands on the ball so much that it's just bound to equal more shot attempts. He's not a PG, he's not going to magically defer to everyone.
What needs to happen is when others get the ball, they need to be aggressive. It's pretty clear that when everyone goes passive, Kobe gets aggressive and vice versa. Finding that happy medium would be ideal, but it's on both parties to do it.
wcsoldier81 wrote:I see it this way :
- I don't like games in which Kobe plays 1 on 5 as soon as the game starts... the rest of the team isn't involved and plays disinterested on both ends off the floor
the pb ? Every player stays passive and passes to Kobe on every possession ...
That's why Nash return will be big ... keep everybody involved AND is competent to make a play... especially down the stretch.
I couldn't care less about our team record when Kobe scores over 30 or attempts 20+ FG ...
wcsoldier81 wrote:I see it this way :
- I don't like games in which Kobe plays 1 on 5 as soon as the game starts ( Houston , Cleveland by instance this season ) because you can feel these are automatic losses ... the rest of the team isn't involved and plays disinterested on both ends off the floor
- Kobe ball has won very few games against a quality opponent for the latest 3 seasons so even when the rest of the team is struggling shooting the ball ( which is far to be the case in every game Kobe shoots a lot) , Kobe taking the majority of the shots won't work ...
the pb ? Every player stays passive and passes to Kobe on every possession ... the only player who would make a play is Metta ... a disaster waiting to happen for the most part... and Dwight is an interior player so somebody has to pass him the rock if he wants to make something happen.
That's why Nash return will be big ... finally a perimeter who will understand when the team has to stay away from Kobe ball , keep everybody involved AND is competent to make a play... especially down the stretch.
I couldn't care less about our team record when Kobe scores over 30 or attempts 20+ FG ...
Kobe ball hasn't been working at all for the last 2-3 seasons so KEEP PLAYING AS A TEAM
Jerry Buss wrote:One of the biggest reasons I bought the Lakers was to beat the Celtics …..you just got it into your soul that you couldn't stand the Celtics anymore
Its like Dr. Buss is guarding the Celtic rim this second half. Nothings dropping
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 13 guests