Hard to say for me, they really only went 6 or 7 deep as far as guys that really contributed anything. It was Dwight, Turkeyglue, Lewis, Lee, Alston, and Pietrus. Nelson came back and actually hurt them, Gortat barely played and hardly scored, the rest were pretty much scrubs. The thing they did have was a perfect roster for Dwight, all those guys could shoot open 3's. In the East, it worked, don't think in the West it would have. If you put our roster now, with Nash in that same East, hard to say what happens, we don't have shooters and playmakers like Turkeyglue.
Overall though, I probably take this roster over that one despite the evidence of them getting to the Finals, but only by a tiny bit, it's a toss up almost to me. Each guy on that roster seems to have laid an absolute egg at least one game in the Finals though, Lewis had a terrible one, 4 points, Lee had a 4 point one, they didn't have a ton of guys to count on in the end other than Howard and Turkeyglue. Alston too should never have been benched, he was playing great with that team and they disrupted that. Maybe with a healthy Nelson to start the playoffs I'd take their roster thinking about it though.