“It was painful,” Lakers forward Pau Gasol(notes) said. “It is a feeling that I want to keep in my mind for every single minute that I’m out there playing them.”


ccameron wrote:John 3:16, he was never in the discussion for league MVP? What are you talking about? He was a perrennial MVP candidate. Even his first season with Lebron, he was a serious mvp candidate. And was he "in the discussion during his 08/09 season? 30.2 pts, 7.5 assists, 5.0 rebounds, 1.3 blocks per game, and player efficiency rating of 30.46? I'm sorry but this is major delusion here.


John3:16 wrote: I said "not that I recall". He came in 3rd place in 09, so yes, he was strongly considered that year. His first year with Lebron (the other year you mentioned) he had like 10 points total. Not first place votes. TOTAL. That's like 10 more then me and you and we didn't even play. Let's just say you were right about 09 and leave his first year with Lebron out of this.
Despite the detailed response, he's not on Kobe's level. Wade is compared to Kobe. Kobe is compared to Jordan. See the difference?
And welcome to the site.
ccameron wrote:Wade has been better than Kobe since that 08/09 season. If you want to argue that, look at the stats first.
As an example, how in the world ESPN ranked him eight last season (behind Derrick Rose and Dwight Howard, who like Wade were injured for much of the season, but had much worse stats, and yes, Kobe, who although he averaged a lot of points had one of the worst shooting years of his career) is beyond me.

@ Wade ever being better than Kobe.
therealdeal wrote:Two things:
Wade isn't in the same stratosphere as Kobe because he has never been outright, head and shoulders better than Kobe Bryant at any point in his career. The 08/09 season is closest. I'd say that's the one season he gets the clear advantage over Bryant. The next season is very comparable. The next season is very comparable, edge to Wade probably. The last two Wade falls apart in comparison.
But he never had a signiture year where he was just WAY better than Kobe Bryant. You can go to 08/09 if you want, but Kobe won a ring that year! And he won another one the year after! Stats can say what they want, but Championships don't lie.
Like John3:16 said, Wade is compared to Kobe. Kobe is compared to Jordan. Not many people would entertain the comparison of Wade to Jordan, would they?
John3:16 wrote:ccameron wrote:Wade has been better than Kobe since that 08/09 season. If you want to argue that, look at the stats first.
Should we start with this years stats?As an example, how in the world ESPN ranked him eight last season (behind Derrick Rose and Dwight Howard, who like Wade were injured for much of the season, but had much worse stats, and yes, Kobe, who although he averaged a lot of points had one of the worst shooting years of his career) is beyond me.
You're gonna fit in around here. We hate BSPN too.
Sorry I forgot to explain: because Kobe HAS been head and shoulders better than Wade. He's been better than him for long periods of time, including the last two years.ccameron wrote:therealdeal wrote:Two things:
Wade isn't in the same stratosphere as Kobe because he has never been outright, head and shoulders better than Kobe Bryant at any point in his career. The 08/09 season is closest. I'd say that's the one season he gets the clear advantage over Bryant. The next season is very comparable. The next season is very comparable, edge to Wade probably. The last two Wade falls apart in comparison.
But he never had a signiture year where he was just WAY better than Kobe Bryant. You can go to 08/09 if you want, but Kobe won a ring that year! And he won another one the year after! Stats can say what they want, but Championships don't lie.
Like John3:16 said, Wade is compared to Kobe. Kobe is compared to Jordan. Not many people would entertain the comparison of Wade to Jordan, would they?
I don't understand this logic at all. Because Wade wasn't WAY better than Kobe, therefore he is not in the same stratosphere as Kobe? Why?
ccameron wrote:And through those two seasons, Kobe was somehow given the benefit of the doubt. Wade doesn't get any of that.
That's why he's given the benefit of the doubt. ccameron wrote:In 10-11, their stats seemed almost identical, but PER showed how much more efficient Wade was. So what were you looking at when you said the comparison falls apart?
ccameron wrote:Also, don't forget Wade was better in 06-07 as well,
ccameron wrote:All of this, and I am willing to concede Kobe will be greater all time than Wade, but enough with the stratosphere nonsense!
Sorry I forgot to explain: because Kobe HAS been head and shoulders better than Wade. He's been better than him for long periods of time, including the last two years.
Why would anyone put Wade in the same sentence as Kobe when 1. Wade has never enjoyed the same level of success as Kobe. Never. and 2. He's never put together a stretch of extended time when he was absolutely better than Kobe Bryant?
And I'm sorry, I just don't stand by PER. I think it's a silly metric and although it was Hollinger's claim to fame, I just don't put any merit into it.
ccameron wrote:therealdeal wrote:Two things:
Wade isn't in the same stratosphere as Kobe because he has never been outright, head and shoulders better than Kobe Bryant at any point in his career. The 08/09 season is closest. I'd say that's the one season he gets the clear advantage over Bryant. The next season is very comparable. The next season is very comparable, edge to Wade probably. The last two Wade falls apart in comparison.
But he never had a signiture year where he was just WAY better than Kobe Bryant. You can go to 08/09 if you want, but Kobe won a ring that year! And he won another one the year after! Stats can say what they want, but Championships don't lie.
Like John3:16 said, Wade is compared to Kobe. Kobe is compared to Jordan. Not many people would entertain the comparison of Wade to Jordan, would they?
I don't understand this logic at all. Because Wade wasn't WAY better than Kobe, therefore he is not in the same stratosphere as Kobe? Why? He doesn't have to be any better to be in the same stratosphere. But take a closer look at those years, and I think you will see that Wad in fact WAS way better. I'm going to use PER because that's the simplest way to show it:
08-09 PER: Wade: 30.46 (2nd in the league), Kobe 24.46 (6th)
09-10 PER: Wade 28.10 (2nd), Kobe 21.95 (15th)
And through those two seasons, Kobe was somehow given the benefit of the doubt. Wade doesn't get any of that.
And what do you mean the last two seasons the comparison falls apart? What are you looking at?
10-11 PER: Wade 25.65 (3rd), Kobe 23.94 (5th)
11-12 PER: Wade 26.37 (3rd), Kobe 21.95 (17th)
In 10-11, their stats seemed almost identical, but PER showed how much more efficient Wade was. So what were you looking at when you said the comparison falls apart? in 2011-12, Kobe seemed to have better stats because he was second in the league in scoring, but it was actually a bad year for Kobe. He shot 43%! Wade on the other hand had less gaudy numbers on less minutes and less shot attempts, but was a lot more efficient.
Also, don't forget Wade was better in 06-07 as well:
06-07 PER: Wade 29.04 (1st), Kobe 26.13 (5th).
The only reason I didn't go that far back is because Wade had a subpar year in 07-08 when he came back from surgery. Other than than year coming back from surgery, Wade has been better. A lot better, if you look at the stats.
And those PER numbers for Kobe are actually pretty repersentative for his whole career. His best years were 2005-2006 (28.11, 3rd in the league), and 2002-2003 (27.07). But in 05-06, Wade was in his third year and was right behind him at 27.68 (4th in the league), and of course he won the championship that year. And in 02-03, of course Wade wasn't even playing yet.
And if you start saying there is something wrong with PER, I don't agree in this case. There have been articles that the weakness of PER is actually that it rewards volume shooters and underrates good defensive players. If anything, that would play in Kobe's favor.
All of this, and I am willing to concede Kobe will be greater all time than Wade, but enough with the stratosphere nonsense!
)Users browsing this forum: davriver290 and 3 guests